pinnapedia IT solutions, thoughts, ideas and some fun

11Dec/092

Blogger vs Joomla vs WordPress

So this is it, welcome to the new home of pinnapedia! The address changed and so did the platform, the author however is the same as always.

On to the fun stuff, changing platform! I have some previous experience working with an Open Source CMS (Content Management System) called Joomla. Joomla isn’t really made for blogs, it’s much more than that. So I was prepared on some workarounds, problems and obstacles. This is where my story begins…

Part 1. Joomla as a blog tooljoomla_vert_logo_90x70

Challenge was my first thought when I started looking at Joomla for the blog, I was right. For a couple of days this site actually held a fully working Joomla-blog! It’s not here anymore and of course there is a reason. I was never interested in paying for a blog plug-in so my experience is only from some free tools. First thing I did was to make a small list of what criterias I had for claiming success, it was something like this:

  • Blog-like layout
  • List for archived posts
  • Support comments
  • Some kind of categorizing similar to tags
  • Static pages supplementing the blog
  • No lack of feature compared to the old blogger (why would I then change?)

Bonus features

  • Import from the old Blogger blog.

Joomla actually managed to give me most of this. The layout was a bigger problem than I could’ve imagined, there are lots and lots of free templates for Joomla out there but almost none aimed at blogging. With some template edits I managed ok but was never quite satisfied. Comments, Categorizing (and tags) was accomplished with a plugin called Lyfftenbloggie. Of the plugins I looked at this was by far the most competent. Still…the posting wasn’t that straight forward, the comments suffered from some bugs, the plugin limited my layout possibilities even more and the archive just looked like…a bag of junk.

I decided that it wasn’t worth it anymore, Joomla is not made for blogging and that was painfully obvious. Next time I'll set up a full homepage though I'm quite certain that it will run on Joomla which is still my number one choice for CMS. This is where WordPress comes into the picture. Wait for Part 2 to get the full story on how I gave up and decided to take the short cut. Part two can be found here: http://einartysen.se/2009/12/blogger-vs-joomla-vs-wordpress-part-2/

Share
Comments (2) Trackbacks (1)
  1. Hey, I am checking this site from my Blackberry and it looks kinda funky. Thought you’d want to know.

  2. I would definately go for WordPress as a final winner. Now between Blogger vs Joomla id go for Joomla as a blog platform. Blogger just has so many negative things and its just not the best in my opinion.
    -Mr.Perfect


Leave a comment


*